Tony Kelly is a criminal who physically and sexually assaulted several people, including a former crush, which resulted in her boyfriends death.
Tony had an obsessive crush on a girl named Carol Soloman in high school and even lied to his mother saying he went to prom with her. However, Carol rejected him, angering Tony. Tony eventually got his revenge on Carol by raping her and attacking her boyfriend, which resulted in his death. Tony and two other men eventually raped and assaulted several other couples, until Tony’s two accomplices were caught. Tony was set free at first but Benson brought Carol to see Tony. Carol doesn’t remember Tony and becomes upset, asking Tony why he did what he did. Tony becomes angry and confesses, then tries to attack Carol, but Benson is able to restrain him. A distraught Carol insults Tony while Benson takes him away, before bursting into tears and Tony is incarcerated.