The unnamed critic is an unwitting accomplice to the rape of interactive theater actress Meghan Weller. She was raped during one of her productions by esteemed judge Gerald Crane, in a rape setup online under her name Crane assumed was consensual. When the critic assumed the rape was part of the act, he held Weller still while she was being raped to participate in the "act".
When she reported the rape backstage and then to the police, the critic was tracked. He told his perspective and was baffled and horrified from hearing the truth. The critic was mostly likely imprisoned for being an accomplice to rape. (SVU: "Theatre Tricks")