SVU, Episode 6.20
Production number: E5224
First aired: 3 May 2005
  th of 476 produced in SVU  
th of 476 released in SVU
  th of 1229 released in all  
Eleanor Duvall.jpg
Teleplay By
Amanda Green

Story By
Amanda Green & Chris Levinson

Directed By
Arthur W. Forney & Juan J. Campanella

Summary[edit | edit source]

A bizarre rape-murder case draws the Special Victims Unit into a web of third-world refugees who claim to have been victimized by a wealthy eccentric. As the detectives get closer to solving the case, one of their own is brutally attacked.

Plot[edit | edit source]

The rape-homicide of a woman leads detectives to a link of illegal immigrants who have each been raped but are too afraid of getting deported to report it. Olivia Benson is able to pull the story from a Bosnian Muslim woman who is very fearful of telling her story, not only because she is at risk of being deported, but because Muslims must be virgins before marriage. Thus, Benson must keep the rape a secret from the woman's brother.

The witness gives Benson money that the perpetrator left on her and after some testing the detectives discover three fingerprints on the bill: One belonging to a bank teller, one belonging to the victim, and one belonging to a local lawyer. The detectives, along with some help from A.D.A. Novak, make a visit to the lawyer and soon discover he is covering up for one of his clients. Following some more clues, they come up with a prime suspect: a man that follows a strict, daily schedule and is paranoid about little things, such as what time he has to eat dinner. The suspect is brought in for questioning, but is immediately released thanks to his lawyer and mother. However, as he leaves the station he complains about a cold. He picks up a tissue out of his pocket and blows into it. As he is about to set it back into his pocket his mother scolds him and tells him to throw it away, which he does. Stabler later picks up the tissue and takes it to the crime lab. Warner says it will take time to run all the tests, but she believes there is make up on the tissue, perhaps that of the original victim's.

The detectives turn to the witness to identify the perpetrator of a line up, but when they arrive at her home they find she was arrested due to her illegal status. The detectives hunt her down and Novak arranges for her to have legal status until she testifies in court, after which she promises to fight for a green card for her. The witness picks Gabriel Duvall out of a line up, and he just happens to be the detectives' prime suspect.

Novak returns to her office along with Benson during the night to work out the details on the case. A phone call comes to Novak's office saying that someone sent her flowers. Novak tells the caller to send them up, however she fears they are from Gabriel's defense attorney. Benson offers to go get some coffee and leaves. Suddenly, a man dressed in black enters with flowers and begins to brutally beat Novak. She suffers several blows to the head and a few kicks as well. Benson returns to her office to find the A.D.A. knocked out on the floor. She calls an ambulance and rides to the hospital with her, while she tells Stabler to check the security cameras.

Stabler decides to make a stop at the Duvall's house. Gabriel demands he leave, but Stabler refuses. He searches around and throws out a few threats before leaving. After checking the security tapes, Stabler finds Gabriel was not behind it. The attacker happened to be the witness' brother. He is arrested and explains that, under his interpretation of fundamentalist Islam, Novak deserved to die as she revealed that his sister wasn't pure. He also reveals that she no longer wishes to testify. Stabler offers to go talk to her, but Cragen demands Novak does. Stabler objects that she is off work and doesn't want to be seen, and Cragen reveals that is why he wants her to go. Novak talks to the witness and she agrees to testify again, however Novak soon finds she is taken off the case. The detectives now have a case against Gabriel for rape, but not for the rape-homicide shown at the beginning of the show.

Stabler soon finds Gabriel's mother has filed a complaint against him and he is no longer allowed around him if he doesn't want the charges to escalate. To calm her, Stabler apologizes to her.

Dr. Warner then calls with good news and Stabler heads to the lab. Warner explains the DNA of the victim is on the tissue in the form of tears.

Stabler finds Gabriel having dinner at a restaurant. Gabriel tells him that his mother informed him of Stabler's apology and he respects that he did it in person before inviting him to dinner. However, Stabler arrests him for the rape.

Cast[edit | edit source]

Main cast[edit | edit source]

Recurring cast[edit | edit source]

Guest cast[edit | edit source]

References[edit | edit source]

Quotes[edit | edit source]

Novak: [after her beating] Did he...did he rape me?
Benson: No.
Novak: Why can't I remember?
Benson: You don't have to. We're gonna find this guy.

Benson: You feel like a cup of coffee?
Novak: Every second of every day.

Stabler: [after a complaint is filed against him by Eleanor Duvall] Captain...
Captain Cragen: Save it. I probably would've thrown Gabriel Duval out the window.

Background information and notes[edit | edit source]

  • This episode is the first half of a two-part crossover with Law & Order: Trial by Jury. The other half is the TBJ episode "Day"
  • When Olivia and Elliot were in the victim's storage unit, they weren't wearing gloves. They are required to wear gloves so they can't contaminate potential evidence.
  • Casey is seen in a baseball jersey stating "Sex Crimes," indicating that she plays baseball on a team that possibly has other ADAs competing against each other.
  • Diane Neal (Casey Novak) stated that the scene in this episode where Casey was knocked unconscious was real; she had really fainted.
  • Alfred Molina, who appears in the SVU/TBJ crossover episodes as Gabriel Duvall, later stars as Detective (and former Deputy District Attorney) Ricardo Morales on Law & Order: LA. He is one of the two actors who appeared on TBJ prior to Law & Order: LA, the other being Peter Coyote (who appeared earlier in the series second episode, "41 Shots" as defense attorney Mike LaSalle.

Episode scene cards[edit | edit source]

1 2 3

The Box
78 Trinity Place
Tuesday, March 1

Apartment of
Sarah Miller
312 East 79th Street
Tuesday, March 1

Law Offices of Granger,
McCullum & Kerstetter
Office of Jason Whitaker
Wednesday, March 2

4 5 6

Duvall Residence
38 East 91st Street
Thursday, March 3

Immigration & Customs
26 Federal Plaza
Friday, March 4

Office of
Assistance District Attorney
Casey Novak
Wednesday, March 9

Previous episode:
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
Season 6
Next episode:
Seasons 123456789101112131415161718192021222324
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.