Sarah Eldon is a teenage nanny for the Davenport socialite family, along with Hannah Price, who was Marjorie Wilden's nanny and revealed to be Sarah's sister.
Background[]
Sarah was the younger sister of the two girls, both of them living in foster care after their mother died and their father couldn't support them. Sarah was adopted by the Eldons, who wanted to take both girls into their home, but Hannah wanted to stay and wait for their father. She was supportive of Sarah's adoption, and to keep in touch, they both got jobs as house staff for wealthy couples who were in the same circles. Hannah helped arrange Sarah to be a part of the Davenport family's staff, replacing nanny Jinny Canto, who was fired after allegations of stealing. In reality, Hannah stole from the Davenports to pin it on Jinny and leave a position open for Sarah. The planned worked, and with Hannah working for Marjorie Wilden, the girls hoped to live out the lives they dreamed of from their favorite childhood soap opera.
Tomorrow[]
At the Davenport house, Bill's son and Tina's stepson Rick realized the sisters' collusion. Being obsessed with Hannah, Rick tried to use it to his advantage and swear to silence in exchange for Hannah being sexually extorted by Rick and his friend Josh Phillips. In retaliation, the girls snapped and brutally killed Rick and Josh. To establish an alibi, Sarah lured Rick's sister Amanda to the scene, murdering her when she arrived. The sisters then posed the kids' bodies to frame Rick for the murders over Josh's and Amanda's relationship, the committing suicide.
Abrasive relationships within the family led the detectives to suspect Tina, but then they found out about Sarah's and Hannah's true identities. They were arrested as the main suspects, but the sisters never sold each other out. Sarah flat out denied the murders, while Hannah bragged the detectives couldn't conclusively tie them to the murders, shouting to Sarah they needed to stay together when they were escorted to their cells.
Sarah and Hannah were both assigned night court attorney Stan Shatenstein, set up by Major Case since he was amateurish enough to not fight a setup, but Bill provided Sarah her own attorney personally. Hannah was horrified she was remanded and facing the death penalty, while Sarah was likely to be released on $2 million dollars. Although Sarah was content over her presumed impunity, Hannah lost it from the two of them being separated and Sarah getting the special treatment Hannah waited her whole life for. She finally sold Sarah out and admitted all the details of the murders, even that Amanda's murder was all Sarah's responsibility. From this, both girls were taken back to their cells.
Known Victims[]
- Jinny Canton (framed for robbing the Davenports)
- The Davenport home killings:
- Rick Davenport (strangled with a belt, then thrown down a trash chute postmortem; framed for the murders and staged his death to look like a suicide)
- Josh Phillips (stabbed)
- Amanda Davenport (stabbed)